Our choices are determined by experts and media personalities. How far do you agree?

For and against points for our choices are determined by experts and media personalities.

  • we are independent and can make our own decisions
  • experts can present technical and complex arguments that cannot be readily understood
  • the internet and electronic systems allow everyone access to goods from across the world, regardless of location
  • those in the media are prone to errors and inconsistencies that undermine their influence
  • art critics are less influential than friends and family in the choices we make
  • despite highly publicised campaigns, people still make consumer choices on price
  • celebrities can be very influential

Skyscrapers make powerful statements. What is your understanding of their significance?

• Tall buildings were found in past civilisations; pyramids in Egypt, medieval cathedrals and fortresses. The towers were a status symbol of the wealthy
• Competition to see who can build the tallest building
• The skyline can be an icon for the city
• Attracts tourists
• Are used when there is a shortage of building land
• A demonstration of the latest technology and architecture
• Symbolises the power and wealth of a state or country
• Often commercial buildings that may stand for financial success or vainglory
• The view! The penthouse
• Can be used to house many people in a small area
• Rooftops can be used as gardens and ways to save energy with solar power

Medicine has been revolutionised by advances in technology. Discuss.

  • we have a moral duty to use technology to help save lives/make lives more comfortable
  • medical technology may go wrong
  • we should not interfere with nature or ‘play God’
  • medical technology can be expensive and time-consuming
  • the treatment of self-inflicted illnesses using such technology presents a moral dilemma
  • such technology might improve the quality of life or prolong the life of some people
  • treatments may only prolong the inevitable and may cause more distress
  • a convincing response should show a keen awareness of the potential tensions inherent in the use of medical technology

To what extent do modern communications isolate us, rather than connect us, to others?

For and against arguments for modern communications isolate us

Keywords: ‘communications’ and ‘isolate’

• May not need to leave the house to communicate
• Lack of physical/human contact
• Can make contact with others in different countries across the world
• Can use social network sites for arranging meetings or events
• Real conversation is replaced by the virtual
The nature of friendship is trivialised
• Re-defines the nature of loneliness

Consider the value of films and/or books which contain material intended to provoke or disturb.

Keywords: ‘consider’, ‘value’, ‘films’, ‘and/or’, ’books’, ‘provoke or disturb’

  • The film or book can be valuable if it is thought-provoking .
  • The value of a movie can be enhanced if it is done with the intention to educate and not to sensationalise.
  • It is important to define ‘disturbing’. Does disturbing equate to sexual, violent, language and horror images?
  • Is the film or book challenging ideologies to encourage discussion or change?
  • What about ‘based on true events.’ Such events could be horrific, disturbing or offensive but need to be shown so that the audience understands the issues.
  • How should content about holocaust, war or some kind of disaster be portrayed without disturbing content?
  • What about ‘disturbing’ for entertainment and shock value?
  • Value could disintegrate if done for sensationalism without attention to character/plot and skilful direction.
  • Some films can have unnecessary language. Language can be gratuitous but can be justified if that is part of the character’s world or environment.

How far would you agree that the Internet is helping to improve the health and well-being of society?

Keywords: ‘How far’ and ‘agree’ and ‘Internet’ and ‘improve’ and ‘health and well-being’.

  • Access to health information from around the world
  • Minor ailments can be self-diagnosed. People are well informed.
  • Encourages more self-awareness
  • People can share common health problems via social media
  • One can join specific groups, especially local support groups
  • Easy to download and print off medical information
  • Plenty of health instructions and videos posted online
  • Can encourage hypochondria and even misdiagnosis
  • Anything can be put on the Internet – selling of suspect medicines, blotched surgery and misinformation
  • People could perceive doctor or hospital visits as unnecessary
  • False information and conflicting information about exercise routines, diet and superfoods

Modern technology used in weapons and communications means that war is now far less likely. To what extent do you agree with this statement?

  • modern technology enables war to be conducted impersonally and at a distance (Read Article1 and Article 2)
  • weapons can act as a deterrent to war; the effects of their devastation are widely acknowledged
  • laser technology allows for greater accuracy of weapons
  • the purpose of satellite surveillance technology is defensive; designed to avoid war
  • in the hands of terrorists or a military dictator, weapons can be used aggressively and can provoke conflict
  • weapons do not cause war or keep the peace; that is the remit of those who control them
  • communication systems can direct weapons.
  • non-lethal weapons can be developed.

‘There are alternative ways to feed the world other than through biotechnology.’ Discuss

Mass hunger still exists alongside a huge food surplus.

There is a need to highlight the politics of food, the ownership of resources, control of markets, and decision-making power.

Consideration of GM claims has increased yields but there is resistance to disease. Some critics say yield gains have been minimal and GM seed is expensive

Technology may decrease biodiversity and contribute to the evolution of superweeds and the consequent use of herbicides creates damage via pesticide drift.

People are still hungry due to economic marginalisation and political impotence

While GM food can solve the problem of hunger, science can encourage the neglect of other priorities; health, education, housing

Support should be given to smallholder farmers and landless rural workers – agro-ecology

“Technology gives us the ability to control our own lives”. How far do you agree or disagree?

We live in a society in which various technologies impact our daily lives ubiquitously. From domestic solar panel heaters that save electricity to smartphone technology that provides applications of different uses for people, technologies have brought abundant convenience and bestowed us with a wider range of abilities to explore and achieve more.  On the other hand, some people accuse that advanced technology is insidious for our personal ability buildup as we heavily rely on its convenience and capability. Consequently, our most basic and crucial skills would be gradually eroded. Those who perceive technology have enslaved us and omit the fact that we are the inventors of these sophisticated mechanisms.  This proves that human brains are far more elastic than what has been found when technology does not serve as a facilitator for us and equip us with capabilities to pursue our goals. It is always up to our choice to terminate their existence. In light of this, I agree with the statement to a large extent. 

 Firstly,  technology can be and has been developed specially and expertly to enhance our abilities with overwhelmingly positive results. One good example is the well documented “Sesame Street Effect” numerous studies showed that children from all sorts of backgrounds and skills who watched the show actually improved in their school readiness, literacy and numeracy abilities as well as social skills. Here, technology was deliberately designed to present an appropriate amount of intellectual stimulation, optimise engagement among young viewers and enable transference to real-life situations. Likewise, we could look at the many groundbreaking websites that are sifting through the noise of data online to help researchers, policymakers and educators refine their communication and data analysis skills.  Khan Academy uses the YouTube platform to help slow learners take all the time they need to revise the High School curriculum. As such technology facilitates education for different groups of people which conventional form of education does not provide and hence gives us the necessary ability to pursue our goals and eventually control our own lives. 

Some may argue that technology encourages the conditions in which skills can be lost without our notice. In giving over many of our simple tasks to technology, we have paid the price for further development in these skills for the extra bit of convenience. For example, the art of cooking has been almost been mechanised over the past decade from premade mixes to pre-packed poultry, from the invention of bread makers to talented multifunctional gadgets at every kitchen needs, we have automated skills that were once considered vital for the initiation of any female into motherhood. In such a way we have regressed in our basic abilities due to the rampant use of the technology. Nevertheless, individuals who are driven to be better at their real-life work, achieving real-life goals and grooming their real-life skills would usually be more focused on how they tap into technologies that help them get there, instead of being overly dependent on technology and passive in enhancing their abilities utilising the assistance of technology. For example, there is a difference between an entrepreneur who uses Twitter, Facebook and his iPhone applications not only for leisure but to communicate with his or her customers and understand market trends versus those only using game technologies to “poke” people, stalk their crushes and play Fruit Ninja. Many successful Web 2.0 businesses like Threadless and Tome Shoes made their millions because their founders intended to establish a successful business using online sources. Thus, more often than not, technology would give those who possess the intentionality to gain more ability what they look forward to. 

Critics may also say that, with the advent of the industrial revolution where advanced nations moved into an era of extensive mechanization, basic skills that were initially done by hand, from harvesting of crops to assembly of complicated parts were largely automated by the late 1900s. This gave rise to Luddites protests that people would lose their jobs as the practising of these basic skills was what was earning them a living. The emergence of technology diminished human work and people’s ability to gain a livelihood. Moreover, our traditional arts in the form of handicrafts have been replaced by standardised manufacturing of products and hence are in great danger of extinction. As such, technology has weakened our ability and willingness in making art pieces using our own hands and would eventually erode our tradition and culture. 

Nevertheless, we should also credit the industrial revolution for freeing people from their mundane chores so that we can strive to learn and innovate increasingly sophisticated skills. More options were given to men, women and children to handle ideal lifestyles instead of endlessly toiling under the sun. They could receive better education and seek better job opportunities which led to a higher standard of living for them. Also, the increase in efficiency brought by machines in the food industry has also helped eradicate global poverty so that famine was no longer a hindrance in industrialized nations for their people to reach a better life quality and even pursue their life goals. Therefore, technology has granted people with time, health and opportunities to acquire sufficient abilities to steer their own life and gain control of it.

 In conclusion, technology with its vast usages and capabilities creates greater access to information for us. Provides us with help in our education and work and most importantly grants us more freedom and efficiency so that we have time to focus on our individual development. Although we can recognise the various instances by which technology has caused us to become less adept, it would be far better for us to acknowledge how technology has improved and enhanced our abilities. As humans, we make use of our intelligence and evolve with the advancement of technology and steward it as a strategic assistant in human development rather than as a monster that is constantly required to be kept on a leash.  As Jonas Salk once stated, “This is perhaps the most beautiful time in human history; it is really pregnant with all kinds of creative possibilities made possible by science and technology which now constitute the slave of man – if man is not enslaved by it.” Indeed, after all, it is us who should make the effort to harness technology in benefiting us and enhancing our abilities to control our lives.